Pilot vs Highlander · Family SUV Face-Off · NYC

Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander: Which 3-Row SUV Should You Buy?

Published November 2, 2026 · Last updated November 13, 2026

Blue Honda Pilot and red Toyota Highlander side by side in front of the New York City skyline, under the headline Which 3-Row SUV Should You Buy?

Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander comes down to space versus efficiency. The Pilot is the bigger SUV, with 4.5 more inches of third-row legroom, more cargo room behind every row and a 285-hp V6, from $42,395. The Highlander answers with a 35-mpg hybrid and standard AWD, from $46,270 (hybrid from $48,020). The next Highlander Toyota has announced is the all-electric 2028 model, due in 2027. Plaza Honda and Plaza Toyota face each other across Nostrand Avenue, so you can try both third rows in one visit.

Quick Verdict

Pilot or Highlander: Which Is Better?

  • Buy the Pilot if you will use the third row: adult-friendlier legroom, eight seats on every trim but the TrailSport, and the bigger cargo area.
  • Buy the Pilot TrailSport if you leave the pavement: a lifted 8.3-inch ground clearance, all-terrain rubber and a tow hitch, from $50,595.
  • Consider the Highlander Hybrid if fuel economy matters most: 35 mpg combined, but the third row is tighter.

Model-year note: Honda has not released 2027 Pilot pricing, so this page compares the 2026 Pilot with the 2026 Highlander and Highlander Hybrid. Toyota's February 10, 2026 release introduces the next Highlander as the battery-electric 2028 model, with up to an estimated 315 miles of range. Toyota expects AWD versions with the 95.8-kWh battery in early 2027 and the XLE FWD in mid-2027, and has not announced its price or said whether gas and hybrid Highlanders continue. More reading: what to expect from the 2027 Pilot, 2026 vs 2027 Honda Pilot and the electric Toyota Highlander for NYC families.

Silver 2026 Honda Pilot parked on a city street, side profile facing left
2026 Honda PilotFrom $42,395 MSRP*
Gray 2026 Toyota Highlander driving along the coast, side profile facing left
2026 Toyota HighlanderFrom $46,270 MSRP*

How Do the Pilot and Highlander Compare at a Glance?

2026 Honda Pilot vs 2026 Toyota Highlander. Sources: Honda's September 9, 2026 Pilot pricing release, Honda Pilot specifications, Toyota's 2026 Highlander release, Toyota pricing and fueleconomy.gov. MSRP excludes $1,595 destination for both. Pilot prices checked November 13, 2026; Highlander prices from Toyota's June 2026 pricing.
Spec2026 Honda Pilot2026 Toyota HighlanderEdge
Starting MSRP$42,395 (Sport FWD); $44,495 AWD$46,270 (XLE, AWD standard)Pilot
Destination$1,595$1,595Tie
Engine3.5L V6, 285 hp, 262 lb-ft, 10-speed2.4L turbo four, 265 hp, 310 lb-ft, 8-speed; or hybrid, 243 hpPilot
EPA combined22 mpg FWD, 21 AWD24 mpg gas; 35 mpg hybridHighlander
Max towing5,000 lb (AWD)5,000 lb gas; 3,500 lb hybridTie
Seating8 (TrailSport 7)7; 8 with optional bench (XLE, Limited)Pilot
Third-row legroom32.5 in28.0 inPilot
Cargo behind 3rd row / max18.6 / 87.0 cu ft16.0 / 84.3 cu ftPilot
Length200.1 in194.9 inHighlander (parking)
Touchscreen12.3 in standard8 in on XLE/XSE; 12.3 in on Limited and PlatinumPilot
Warranty3 yr/36,000 mi basic; 5 yr/60,000 mi powertrainSame, plus hybrid battery 10 yr/150,000 mi and ToyotaCare (2 yr/25,000 mi maintenance, 2 yr roadside)Highlander

Want Today's Price on a Pilot?

Let us know the Pilot trim, color and drivetrain you want and how to reach you. Plaza Honda will reply with the Pilots on hand, the Plaza price with this month's offers and a time to drive one, and can line up a Highlander drive next door at Plaza Toyota.

How Much Bigger Is the Pilot?

The Pilot is 200.1 inches long, 5.2 inches longer than the 194.9-inch Highlander (the Highlander XSE is 197.4). That length goes into the cabin, so the Pilot wins every space measurement below, while the Highlander is easier to slot into a tight Brooklyn curb space. If you like the Highlander but need more room, see how Toyota's two 3-row SUVs compare.

Red 2026 Honda Pilot with a roof box crossing a shallow stream, front three-quarter view facing left
2026 Honda Pilot200.1 in long
Blue 2026 Toyota Highlander driving on a dirt road, front three-quarter view facing left
2026 Toyota Highlander194.9 in long

Which Has the Roomier Third Row?

Its third row has 32.5 inches of legroom against 28.0 in the Highlander, a 4.5-inch difference that decides whether teens and adults fit back there. Second-row legroom also favors the Pilot, 40.8 inches to 38.7. Every Pilot except the 7-seat TrailSport seats eight, and on the 8-seat trims from the EX-L up you can remove the middle second-row seat and stash it under the cargo floor, leaving a walk-through to the third row. The Highlander seats seven, or eight with the optional second-row bench on the XLE and Limited. To see how the Pilot's cabin stacks up against Honda's minivan, read Honda Pilot vs Odyssey.

2026 Honda Pilot brown leather second-row captain's chairs with the third row behind
2026 Honda Pilot32.5 in third-row legroom
2026 Toyota Highlander gray second-row captain's chairs and third row under the moonroof
2026 Toyota Highlander28.0 in third-row legroom

Which Has More Cargo Space?

The Pilot holds 18.6 cubic feet behind the third row, 2.6 more than the Highlander's 16.0, room for an extra stroller with every seat in use. With the third row folded they are nearly even, 48.5 to 48.4. Behind the front seats, the Pilot reaches 87.0 cubic feet against 84.3.

2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport climbing a sandy trail, rear three-quarter view
2026 Honda Pilot18.6 cu ft behind the third row
Red 2026 Toyota Highlander driving out of a garage, rear three-quarter view
2026 Toyota Highlander16.0 cu ft behind the third row

Which Has More Power, Towing and MPG?

All Pilots share one powertrain: a 285-hp, 262-lb-ft 3.5-liter V6 paired with a 10-speed automatic. AWD is optional on the Sport and EX-L and standard above them. The gas Highlander uses a 2.4-liter turbo four with 265 hp and 310 lb-ft and an 8-speed, with standard AWD. Both tow up to 5,000 pounds with AWD; the Highlander Hybrid tows 3,500. EPA ratings favor Toyota: the Pilot gets 22 mpg combined with FWD and 21 with AWD, the gas Highlander 24 and the 243-hp Highlander Hybrid 35. There is no Pilot hybrid. Trim-by-trim mpg is in our 2027 Pilot guide, which compares every current trim.

Gray 2026 Honda Pilot towing a small camper up a rocky trail, side view facing right
2026 Honda PilotUp to 5,000 lb towing (AWD)
Gray 2026 Toyota Highlander parked by snowy mountains, side profile facing right
2026 Toyota Highlander5,000 lb gas; 3,500 lb hybrid

Which Has Better Safety and Technology?

The Pilot gives you more screen on every trim: a 12.3-inch touchscreen and a 10.2-inch digital cluster are standard, with Google built-in and wireless CarPlay and Android Auto. The Highlander XLE and XSE start with an 8-inch screen; the 12.3-inch display is optional there and standard on the Limited and Platinum. Honda Sensing is standard on the Pilot, and Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+ on the Highlander. Neither one made the IIHS 2026 award list. In the updated moderate overlap test, the Pilot rates Acceptable and the Highlander Marginal.

2026 Honda Pilot dashboard with the 12.3-inch touchscreen, seen from the driver's door
2026 Honda Pilot12.3-in screen standard
Driver reaching for the 12.3-inch touchscreen in a 2026 Toyota Highlander, with the full steering wheel and digital gauges in view
2026 Toyota Highlander8 in standard; 12.3 in on Limited, Platinum

Recalls and Warranty: What Should Owners Expect?

NHTSA's recall records list one recall for the 2026 Pilot, campaign 26V424000, which covers rear subframe bolts and is repaired free at any Honda dealer. The 2026 Highlander and Highlander Hybrid show none so far. Base coverage matches: 3 years or 36,000 miles bumper to bumper and 5 years or 60,000 miles on the powertrain. Toyota adds more on top: 10 years or 150,000 miles on the hybrid battery, plus ToyotaCare, which covers factory-scheduled maintenance for 2 years or 25,000 miles and roadside assistance for 2 years. Honda's Pilot page lists roadside assistance but no complimentary maintenance plan. Pilot owners can book service at Plaza Honda, at the same address where they buy. For how the two brands compare beyond these SUVs, read Honda vs Toyota.

How Do Pilot and Highlander Trims and Prices Compare?

2026 Honda Pilot trims vs 2026 Toyota Highlander grades, from Honda's Pilot pricing (checked November 13, 2026) and Toyota's June 2026 pricing. MSRP excludes $1,595 destination for both.
TrimMSRP*PowertrainEPA combined
Pilot Sport$42,395 (AWD $44,495)V6, FWD or AWD22 / 21 mpg
Pilot EX-L$44,695 (AWD $46,795)V6, FWD or AWD22 / 21 mpg
Pilot TrailSport$50,595V6, AWD20 mpg
Pilot Touring$51,295V6, AWD21 mpg
Pilot Touring Blackout$52,495V6, AWD21 mpg
Pilot Elite$53,695V6, AWD21 mpg
Pilot Black Edition$55,195V6, AWD21 mpg
Highlander XLE$46,2702.4T, AWD24 mpg
Highlander XSE$48,3402.4T, AWD24 mpg
Highlander Limited$50,7252.4T, AWD24 mpg
Highlander Platinum$53,9252.4T, AWD24 mpg
Highlander Hybrid XLE$48,020Hybrid, AWD35 mpg
Highlander Hybrid Limited$52,475Hybrid, AWD35 mpg
Highlander Hybrid Platinum$55,675Hybrid, AWD35 mpg

AWD to AWD, the Pilot Sport is $1,775 less than the Highlander XLE, and a FWD Pilot Sport saves $3,875. A front-drive Pilot EX-L, with leather seats, costs $1,575 less than the base Highlander; with AWD it is $525 more. At the top, the Pilot Elite undercuts the gas Highlander Platinum by $230, while the Pilot Black Edition costs $1,270 more than the gas Platinum and $480 less than the Hybrid Platinum. Families shopping now can review current Pilot incentives, start a loan or lease application and price their trade-in.

Honda Pilot in Stock at Plaza Honda

Pilots from the Sport up through the TrailSport and Black Edition are listed below, including incoming units, and you can browse the full new Honda Pilot inventory any time. Ring (855) 528-6785 with the trim and seating layout you want and we will have one parked out front; delivery inside 25 miles is free. Want to drive both? Check the Highlanders in stock at Plaza Auto Mall, then get directions to Plaza Honda at 2740 Nostrand Avenue.

Black 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L at Plaza Honda, NY
Stock # 263748IN TRANSIT
Disclosure
Gray 2026 Honda Pilot Touring for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2026 Honda Pilot Touring for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2026 Honda Pilot Touring for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot Touring at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot Touring at Plaza Honda, NY
Disclosure
Black 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NY
Disclosure
Black 2024 Honda Pilot EX-L 7 Passenger for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2024 Honda Pilot EX-L 7 Passenger for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2024 Honda Pilot EX-L 7 Passenger for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2024 Honda Pilot EX-L 7 Passenger at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2024 Honda Pilot EX-L 7 Passenger at Plaza Honda, NY
Stock # HN2982PCertified Pre-Owned
Silver 2023 Honda Pilot Touring for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2023 Honda Pilot Touring for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2023 Honda Pilot Touring for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2023 Honda Pilot Touring at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2023 Honda Pilot Touring at Plaza Honda, NY
Gray 2026 Honda Pilot Elite for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2026 Honda Pilot Elite for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2026 Honda Pilot Elite for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot Elite at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot Elite at Plaza Honda, NY
Disclosure
Blue 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L at Plaza Honda, NY
Disclosure
White 2026 Honda Pilot Elite for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2026 Honda Pilot Elite for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2026 Honda Pilot Elite for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot Elite at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot Elite at Plaza Honda, NY
Disclosure
White 2023 Honda Pilot Elite for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2023 Honda Pilot Elite for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2023 Honda Pilot Elite for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2023 Honda Pilot Elite at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2023 Honda Pilot Elite at Plaza Honda, NY
Stock # HN2827Certified Pre-Owned
White 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L at Plaza Honda, NY
Stock # 263726IN TRANSIT
Disclosure
White 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NY
Black 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NY
Stock # 263743IN TRANSIT
Disclosure
Black 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2026 Honda Pilot EX-L at Plaza Honda, NY
Stock # 263722IN TRANSIT
Disclosure
Black 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NY
Blue 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NYPhotos of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaAnother view of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport for sale in Brooklyn, NY at Plaza HondaMore photos of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NYMore photos of 2024 Honda Pilot TrailSport at Plaza Honda, NY

Which Should You Buy, the Pilot or the Highlander?

Buy: Pilot EX-L

Best family value

Leather seating for eight and a removable middle seat for $44,695.

Buy: Pilot TrailSport

For weekends upstate

Skid plates, trail tires and 8.3 inches of clearance for $50,595.

Buy: Pilot Elite

Most comfort

Head-up display, ventilated seats and heated second row for $53,695.

Consider: Highlander Hybrid

Fuel economy first?

35 mpg combined from $48,020 at Plaza Toyota, with a tighter third row.

Pilot vs Highlander Scorecard

CategoryWinnerWhy
Starting pricePilot$3,875 less to start; $1,775 less AWD to AWD
Third rowPilot4.5 in more legroom; eight seats on every trim but the TrailSport
CargoPilot2.6 cu ft more behind the third row
PowerPilot285-hp V6 vs 265-hp turbo four
TechnologyPilot12.3-in screen and Google built-in standard
Fuel economyHighlander24 mpg gas, 35 mpg hybrid vs 21–22
Warranty and included careHighlanderHybrid battery 10 yr/150,000 mi; ToyotaCare 2 yr/25,000 mi maintenance
NHTSA recalls, 2026 modelsHighlanderNone so far vs one for the Pilot
Overall for NYC familiesPilotMore room for people and gear, for less money

Still deciding? See the Pilot against every major 3-row rival in Honda Pilot vs the competition. Then measure the Pilot against Toyota's larger 3-row SUV, or set it beside Hyundai's 3-row SUV and Kia's 3-row SUV. Staying with Honda? Read Honda Passport vs Pilot.

The Pilot comes to you. Plaza Honda's free home delivery covers a 25-mile radius around the dealership, taking in the five boroughs and most of Nassau County, and our service department can collect and return your SUV anywhere in the NYC metro area.

Arrange Pilot Delivery

Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander: Frequently Asked Questions

Which is more reliable, the Pilot or the Highlander?

Neither Honda nor Toyota publishes a reliability score. NHTSA lists one recall for the 2026 Pilot, for rear subframe bolts, and none so far for the 2026 Highlander or Highlander Hybrid. Both carry a 3-year/36,000-mile basic and 5-year/60,000-mile powertrain warranty. Toyota also covers the hybrid battery for 10 years or 150,000 miles and includes 2 years or 25,000 miles of scheduled maintenance through ToyotaCare.

Is the Pilot bigger than the Highlander?

Yes. The Pilot is 200.1 inches long against 194.9 for the Highlander, with 32.5 inches of third-row legroom against 28.0 and 18.6 cubic feet of cargo space behind the third row against 16.0.

Does the Honda Pilot come as a hybrid?

No. Every 2026 Pilot uses a 285-hp 3.5-liter V6, rated 20 to 22 mpg combined, and Honda has not announced a hybrid version. Shoppers who want a hybrid three-row SUV can compare the Highlander Hybrid, rated 35 mpg combined and priced from $48,020.

Which gets better gas mileage?

The Highlander. The gas Highlander is rated 24 mpg combined and the Highlander Hybrid 35, while the Pilot is rated 20 to 22 mpg combined depending on trim and drivetrain.

Does the Honda Pilot have AWD?

Yes. AWD is standard on the Pilot TrailSport, Touring, Touring Blackout, Elite and Black Edition and available on the Sport and EX-L for $2,100. Every 2026 Highlander has AWD as standard.

Is the Toyota Highlander going electric?

Yes. Toyota's next Highlander is a battery-electric 2028 model with up to an estimated 315 miles of range. Toyota expects the AWD versions with the 95.8-kWh battery to go on sale in early 2027 and the XLE FWD in mid-2027, and has not announced pricing or said whether gas and hybrid Highlanders continue alongside it.

Sources: automobiles.honda.com Pilot pricing and Honda's 2026 Pilot specifications; Toyota's September 5, 2025 announcement of the 2026 Highlander, June 2026 pricing, ToyotaCare and warranty terms; Toyota's February 10, 2026 release on the 2028 Highlander; EPA ratings on fueleconomy.gov; IIHS ratings; NHTSA recall records (checked November 13, 2026).

*MSRP excludes $1,595 destination for both, plus tax, title and registration. 2028 Highlander details and timing are Toyota estimates; pricing has not been announced. EPA figures are estimates; expect different results in daily use. Pilot prices and recalls checked November 13, 2026; Highlander prices from Toyota's June 2026 pricing. Contact Plaza Honda with questions.